Hear, everyone who thirsts;
come to the waters;
and you who have no money,
come, buy and eat!
Come, buy wine and milk
without money and without price.
Why do you spend your money for that which is not bread
and your earnings for that which does not satisfy?
Listen carefully to me, and eat what is good,
and delight yourselves in rich food.
Incline your ear, and come to me;
listen, so that you may live.
I will make with you an everlasting covenant,
my steadfast, sure love for David.
See, I made him a witness to the peoples,
a leader and commander for the peoples.
Now you shall call nations that you do not know,
and nations that do not know you shall run to you,
because of the Lord your God, the Holy One of Israel,
for he has glorified you.
Seek the Lord while he may be found;
call upon him while he is near;
let the wicked forsake their way
and the unrighteous their thoughts;
let them return to the Lord, that he may have mercy on them,
and to our God, for he will abundantly pardon.
For my thoughts are not your thoughts,
nor are your ways my ways, says the Lord.
For as the heavens are higher than the earth,
so are my ways higher than your ways
and my thoughts than your thoughts.
~Isaiah 55:1-9 (NRSVUE)
 |
Girl Drinking Water in Rwanda (from Partners in Health Initiative) Courtesy of Art in the Christian Tradition, Vanderbilt University Divinity Library |
Sermon
Yesterday I read this invitation to reflect. As I read it to you now, I invite you to listen and reflect on the questions it asks.
Imagine yourself when you were 6 years old. Do you remember what you were going through when you turned 10? Remember how you felt at 16? Do you remember your dreams at 21? All those versions of who you used to be are still inside of you. Your 7-year-old self still gets excited when you remember the joy of that day. Your 35-year-old self still wants to cry when remembering the pain of that year. Like a nesting doll, every version of you has been a part of you becoming who you are today. Some versions of you went through some terrible and painful experiences and some felt great joy. But all versions of you were held by God. [1]
I did yesterday what I just invited you to do now. Some of my memories were quite vivid. Other years had so many associations with them it was hard to find a single, real connection. For age 6, I remembered a long-forgotten bulky blue cardigan that someone had knitted for me, and also my sudden fierce need for pierced ears. Also Davy Jones. He was part of the picture somehow.
The most striking thing here, though, is the truth that each of is still all these people—the 6-year-old in the blue sweater, the 10-year-old who has changed schools, the 16-year-old playing Grandma Tzeitel in “Fiddler on the Roof.” They are all the same person who gave birth at ages 26 and 31, who graduated from seminary at 42, and who stands in front of you now at… the age I am now. Each of those moments informed the person I was to become in small ways and large, and each of you can say the same of your 6-year-old and 10-year-old and your every-age selves.
And so it goes with communities. We are in the portion of the prophet Isaiah when the matter at hand is the Babylonian exile. In chapters 40 through 55, the prophet is comforting the afflicted: speaking to those who have been taken into exile and who have suffered the loss of their leadership and religious practices. Their King Zedekiah, who had tried to resist Babylon by forming an alliance with two other nations, was eventually arrested along with his family. His sons were executed as Zedekiah looked on, after which Zedekiah himself was blinded.
Portions of the Lamentations of Jeremiah describe the horrors of exile vividly:
The tongue of the infant sticks
to the roof of its mouth for thirst;
the children beg for food,
but there is nothing for them.
Those who feasted on delicacies
perish in the streets;
those who were brought up in purple
cling to ash heaps.
~ Lamentations 4:4-5
There are much worse verses than these.
At the same time, the Judeans who were carried away and were living lives of deprivation and desperation still had memories of home. They remembered the magnificent Temple built by Solomon with the same kind of love Jesus had for it. They remembered the many festivals they had celebrated there with their own kin. Their lives, too, carried layer upon layer of memory—the joys of home layered with the trauma, grief, and loss of exile. And even when the exile came to an end about seventy years after it began people carried their own, their parents’ and their grandparents’ memories—joy layered with trauma, grief, and loss.
How do we find the people still in exile, but suddenly facing the prospect of returning home? Most likely we find them with a mixture of emotions. Hope? Doubt? Fear? Isaiah calls to them, You who are thirsty—come to the waters! He knows they are thirsty for fresh, clear water. In Babylon they had to purchase all their water and carry it home. And they are spiritually empty. They are thirsty for God. Is their thirst mingled with their own or their parents’ memories of drinking fresh, clear water when they were children? Are they imagining what the water at home in Judea is like now? Isaiah is inviting them to remember and to imagine.
Come, the prophet says. Buy milk and wine and bread without money. Your God will supply your needs. Why buy the things that don’t satisfy? Remember the land of milk and honey? It awaits you.
As their time in exile comes to an end, the prophet asks the weary, disheartened people to imagine this wonderful homecoming. A homecoming that restores them to the abundance they’ve longed for—both materially and spiritually. It’s not just water: it’s the living water God promises, which will quench their thirst forever. It’s not just groceries, it’s an abundance of the heart, the steadfast love of God. Eat and drink what is good; delight in it. It is free! It will satisfy for the long term. Imagine!
God offers to remake God’s covenant with David; now the covenant will be with the people. They can trust God to be their protector, the one who will supply them with all they need. No intermediary is necessary—not even a king. But there’s one catch: it has to do with the people’s relationship with God. Seek the Lord, Isaiah urges them, who is still to be found. Call upon God, who is yet at hand. Isaiah is talking about repentance.
For the exiles returning home, a huge issue is the question of why they are there to begin with. You could point to different mistakes different kings made along the way, or their leaders’ unfaithfulness. You could point to the people losing their connection with God even before they were carried away physically. Do the people need to repent these things? Sure. But repentance here might not mean what we tend to think it means.
Repentance is not about: You were evil, now you’re planning to be good. It’s not about God throwing you into the “lost” or “broken” bin, and you needing to figure out how to climb out of the thing. That’s not it. Repentance is not a bootstraps project.
The word we translate “repentance” simply means turning around. It’s about changing your view, your point of view. Looking at things in a new way.
Father Gregory Boyle is a Jesuit priest in Los Angeles who founded “Homeboy Industries,” the largest gang member rehabilitation and re-entry program in the world. Father Greg describes it this way: “We imagine a world without prisons, and then we try to create that world.” In a Lenten reflection a couple of years ago, Father Greg shared a story about a young man he worked with. He wrote,
A gang member, Louie, sat in my office at Homeboy Industries and was sobbing. “How come everyone here loves me?” The crying intensifies. “I mean…everyday…I take myself to court…and everyday…I find myself guilty.” He thinks a bit. “I signed on the dotted line…to everything I’ve done. If you knew who I really am…it would dissuade you…from loving me.”
Repent.
It means “to move beyond the mind you have.” It doesn’t mean “do good and avoid evil.” It is about seeing things differently. There is an invitation in it to embrace the mystical view; to see as God does. Louie needs to recognize his own unshakeable goodness. No need to become someone he is not. The gentle urging of our tender God is for Louie to recognize what has been there all along. He needs to move beyond the mind he has, so he can see it. [2]
Repentance is simply seeing yourself the way God sees you. For the exiles, that meant seeing their own unshakeable goodness, seeing themselves as beloved children of God, despite what had happened to them, despite their sense of responsibility or guilt. It meant their understanding that through all they had experienced—the memories of long ago as well as the trauma of exile—God was holding them. God never let them go.
Repentance for us is the same. You, too, are unshakably good. You are God’s beloved. God loves you with an everlasting love. God has called you by name, and you belong to God. No need to take yourself to court everyday and find yourself guilty. That’s not the mindset God wants for you. That’s not the life God wants for you.
Do you have a hard time seeing yourself this way? I think most of us do. How about this: Imagine it. Imagine yourself—that 6-year-old you, that 21-year-old you, that your-age-today you, and imagine that you are God’s beloved, and you always have been. Imagine your own unshakeable goodness. Imagine that, just as God is offering the exiles a warm welcome home, God has that welcome ready for you, every minute, every day. You have been at home with God all along. God has always been holding you. God never let you go.
In a chaotic world, this love of God can be our still point, our north star, the rock on which we stand. When we wake up and the news that blinks up at us from our phone horrifies us, God is there. When we wonder when the fighting will cease, whether in Eastern Europe or the Middle East, God is there. When we wonder what our role might be in this strange and unsettling time, God is there. God is holding us. God never let us go.
Imagine that.
Thanks be to God. Amen. [3]
[1] Brenda Thompson, MDiv, Angela Taylor, MDiv, Hailie Durrett, and Karen Bowler, PhD, “The Hardest Part: Pain We Carry, Joy We Find,” Sermon Guide, The Everything Happens Project, KateBowler.com, 2025.
[2] Fr. Gregory Boyle, S. J., “First Sunday of Lent: Seeing Things Differently,” February 21, 2021, Ignatian Solidarity Blog, https://ignatiansolidarity.net/blog/2021/02/21/seeing-things-differently/.
[3] "Imagine!" Concept and resources thanks to [1]